"Maya Sita" and "Maya Radha"

[Paramananda das]

dear devotess
Dandavat pranams
All glories to Srila Prabhupada
I had a question, and yesterday HH Van Maharaja from Kesavaji Gaudiya math in Mahura answered the question nicely on an Internet talk on face book,he is a disciple of Vamana Maharaja , below is my question:

my dear Van Maharaja
Please accept my humble obaisences
All glories to Srila Prabhupada
I was reading in Gopala Campu how Sankacuda grapped Radharanis hair when he kidnapped Her and the Gopis, it made me very sad,,I was thinking about the Brahmin that asked Lord Caitanya about the kidnapping of Sita in the CC..I am very sad to think of such a sinful demon could touch Sri Radha.. but there must be some explanation...but I am not aware of it.In Bhagavatam Sankacuda is described as simply controlling the Gopis wiht a stick but not actually touching any of them.
your servant
Paramananda  das

You will see how HH Van Maharaja is such a humble devotee and his answer is amazing sorry about the spelling:





10:31pmSripad
what is that u write some thing

10:31pmPayonidhi Das
pranams

10:32pmSripad
i do not so much in computre

10:32pmPayonidhi Das
I asked you about it is mentioned in Lalita Madhava

10:32pmSripad
thank u so much your loving words

10:32pmPayonidhi Das


my question is this Maharaja

in Lalita Madhava act 2

text 99

it has been mentioned by RupaGoswamipada

that Sankacuda graped the hair of Sri Radha

this is giving me some pain,how this asura could touch the transcendental body of Radha?


10:37pmSripad
as like chaya sita kidnep ed by ravan

10:37pmPayonidhi Das
yes that I was thinking to Like maya Sita

but where is the sastra pranam for this "maya Radha" ?

10:38pmSripad
onlt krishana can touch to radha

10:38pmPayonidhi Das
yes of course

10:38pmSripad
some in the comentry of goswami

10:39pmPayonidhi Das
but like the brahmin was only happy when Mahaprabhu brought some pages from Kurma Purana

I have asked many learned devotees, but no one has been abel to give me the sastra praman

from the acaryas to this

but of course we understand this can never be Radha

10:40pmSripad
in this is call ed upalaskhan

10:40pmPayonidhi Das
which means?

10:41pmPayonidhi Das
what is the meaning of Upalaskhan?

10:42pmSripad
upalaskhan means every thing to understand santra tatpyarja

10:42pmPayonidhi Das
yes

10:42pmSripad
give an exmpale gangayam ghose palli

10:43pmPayonidhi Das
what is the meaning?

10:44pmSripad
lilitmadhav has written by rupa goswami so all ready maha prabhu ptoved chay sita so rupa goswami in this way expalin this lila

10:45pmPayonidhi Das
accha...yes that makes sense

supporting evidence

so a chaya Radha is quit possible if even it takes place in Lord Ramas Lila

that makes sense and Radha krsna lila is superior

10:46pmSripad
yes

10:46pmPayonidhi Das
very nice explanation Maharaja

wonderfull

thank you so much

10:47pmSripad
u may comtract with my mail gmail.com

10:47pmPayonidhi Das
I am feeling so much ananda by your explantion

what is your gmail Maharaja?

10:48pmSripad
i am not looking facebook

[e-mail]

10:48pmPayonidhi Das
yes i understand Maharaja I will send email to your gmail only

thank you


10:49pmSripad
l means lila

10:49pmPayonidhi Das


10:49pmSripad
thank you for your hospitality

do not take my offence

10:50pmPayonidhi Das
I never have given you any service I am so unfortunate

10:50pmSripad
dandabat pranams

10:50pmPayonidhi Das
you please forgive me for my millions of aparadhas

at your lotusfeet

I am highly blessed with you Sadhu sanga

I still do not know what is Upalaskhan or what are these other sanskrit words Maharaja was trying to convey, but this Chay Radha or Maya Radha is thus explained, and when I asked Deenabandhu Prabhu he said he even felt the siddhanta being correct.Of this I have no doubt also, it was such a sweet exchange and Maharaja is a very dear friend of mine,and very kind,so it was extra nice.
Thought I should share it.
Your humble servant
 Paramananda das